Playbooks

Good, Better, Best Proposals for Solar, Roofing and Exteriors: Build Three Options Homeowners Can Choose From

Good must fix the whole problem. Better and Best add what the homeowner asked for. Sample packages for roofing, solar and siding, and how to present them.

GameForce Team

Good, Better, Best Proposals for Solar, Roofing and Exteriors: Build Three Options Homeowners Can Choose From title card

One proposal asks for a yes or a no. Three options ask a better question: which one fits you? A good, better, best proposal works when each option is a complete, honest answer to the homeowner's problem, and each step up adds something they asked for. It fails when the cheapest option is a decoy or the three differ only in labels.

Here is how to build the three for solar, roofing and exterior jobs, with sample packages, a way to present the middle option, and what open and read time tell you about the follow up.

Five rules for building the three

  1. Good fixes the whole problem. If the roof leaks, Good stops the leak and replaces what is damaged. Never build a weak first option to make the others look better. Homeowners can tell, and it costs you trust on all three.
  2. Each step up adds one to three things the homeowner can see or feel. A battery, a longer warranty, a better shingle, gutter guards. Not ten line items with names they cannot pronounce.
  3. Tie every upgrade to something they said. "You mentioned the power went out twice last winter" is the reason the battery is in Best.
  4. Same rows, same order, on all three. The homeowner should be able to read across a row and see exactly what changes.
  5. Say what is not included. Permits, removal of a second layer of shingles, electrical panel work, or trim. If it might come up, it goes on the page.

Sample packages by trade

These are samples to adapt. Swap the brackets for your own products, warranties and terms, and keep every price and payment to what your own price book and lender documents say.

Roofing replacement

  • Good: tear off and replace with [architectural shingles], replace damaged decking as found, new [underlayment], drip edge and pipe boots, [workmanship warranty], full cleanup.
  • Better: everything in Good, plus [synthetic underlayment], [ridge vent] and an upgraded [manufacturer warranty].
  • Best: everything in Better, plus [impact resistant shingles] and [gutter guards].

If you offer impact resistant shingles, here is a fact worth sharing: the Texas Department of Insurance home insurance guide lists an impact resistant roof among the features that might earn a discount, and says each company decides its own discounts. Tell the homeowner to ask their agent before they count on one. On an insurance claim job, keep the upgrades the homeowner pays for apart from the claim scope; the insurance claims guide covers the deductible rules.

Solar

  • Good: a system sized to cover [part] of the past year's use, with [panel and inverter warranty] and monitoring.
  • Better: a larger system sized to [most] of the past year's use, same warranties.
  • Best: the Better system plus [a battery] for backup during outages.

Show the monthly payment, the term and any yearly increase on every option, side by side. No savings promise you cannot show from the homeowner's own bills. The monthly payment guide covers how to put the payment next to the bill.

Siding, windows and gutters

  • Good: replace the failing [south wall siding] or the [four windows] the homeowner pointed out.
  • Better: the whole house in the same product, so every wall matches.
  • Best: the whole house plus [insulated siding or house wrap] and [matching trim and gutters].

Present the middle option first

Start with the option that best fits what you heard, which is usually Better, and say why. Then walk down and up. A sample, for a roof:

Based on what you told me, the leak over the kitchen and wanting this to be the last roof on this house, I'd look at Better first. Here's what's in it. Good also fixes the leak and replaces the damaged decking; what you give up is the upgraded underlayment and the longer warranty. Best adds impact resistant shingles and gutter guards. Which of these feels closest to what you want?

Then stop talking. Let them read across the rows. If they ask about one line, answer that line. If they pick Good, thank them and write it up; it is a complete job.

Make the payment honest

If you show a monthly payment, show the term, the rate source and any increase on all three options, from the lender's own documents. Never round a rate or estimate one at the table. If the homeowner asks a financing question you cannot answer from the paperwork, write it down and get the answer from the lender, in writing.

A homeowner choosing between three payments should also see the total. A lower payment over a longer term is not a cheaper job, and saying so builds more trust than any close.

Send it, then read the signals

Many proposals get a second look after the visit, often with a spouse or a parent who was not at the table. When you can see when a proposal is opened and how long it was read, use it to time your follow up, not to pressure:

  • Not opened after two days: call once. "Did the proposal come through? I can walk you through it in ten minutes."
  • Opened once, quick look: they glanced at it. Offer a short call to go over the options.
  • Opened several times, long reads: they are comparing. Call with "Any questions on the three options? Happy to go over any line."
  • Opened again after a quiet week: something brought it back up. Call and ask what questions came up.

Never say "I saw you opened it four times." Say what you can help with. The solar objections guide covers the questions that come up at this stage.

After the yes

When the homeowner picks an option, the signed scope goes to production exactly as written: the option, any changes made at the table, what is not included and any date the homeowner asked for (marked as a request until production confirms it). For sales signed at the kitchen table, the cooling off rule guide covers the cancellation paperwork to hand over, and the signed to paid guide maps the job from here to the final payment.

Once a quarter, check which option homeowners pick. If nearly everyone picks Good, Better may not be adding what people want. If nobody picks Best, swap one of its upgrades for something homeowners ask about.

Proposals in GameForce

  • Good, better, best packages with the monthly payment
  • Our own e-signature, in person or by link
  • See when they open it, and how long they read

Build the three from your own price book, sign at the table or by link, and time the follow up by the open and read signals above.

FAQ

Should every proposal have three options?

When the job has real choices, yes. When there is only one sound way to do the work, show one complete option and explain why. Never invent a difference just to fill three columns.

Should the cheapest option ever leave out needed work?

No. Good must fully fix the problem. Upgrades go in Better and Best; necessary repairs go in all three.

Is the middle option always the right recommendation?

No. Recommend the option that matches what the homeowner told you, and say why. Better is often that option because it is built around common asks, but a homeowner who only wants the leak fixed may be best served by Good.

What does it mean when a homeowner opens the proposal several times?

Usually that they are comparing options or showing someone else. Call to offer help with any line, and do not mention how many times they opened it.

Build your three options

Book a demo and bring a recent proposal you would like to split into three, or start a free trial.

Put your next step into practice.

See what a clearer sales day can look like.

Read next