Playbooks

Choosing a Dialer for a Small Insurance Agency: Modes, Lists and Compliance Basics

The lead source picks the mode. The FCC rule sets the basics. What a small agency needs before the first call, including the rules for recorded voicemails.

GameForce Team

Choosing a Dialer for a Small Insurance Agency: Modes, Lists and Compliance Basics title card

This is general information, not legal advice. Laws change and differ by state. Talk to a lawyer about your own calls and texts.

The short answer: for a small insurance agency, let the lead source pick the dialing mode, and keep the line count low enough that every answered call reaches a licensed agent who is ready to talk. Before the first call, put six federal basics in place: calling hours, the national registry, your own do not call list, written consent for autodialed or recorded calls, the rules for recorded voicemails and the abandoned call limit. The rules below are from the FCC's telemarketing rule, 47 CFR 64.1200.

Let the lead source pick the mode

  • Fresh quote requests: call within minutes, one lead at a time, with the agent's full attention. The speed to lead guide gives the routine.
  • Aged leads: power dialing at one line. Every answered call reaches a ready agent, and the agent reads the record before the call connects. Check how old the consent is first; the aged leads guide covers how to sort an old list.
  • Renewals, cross sells and callbacks: one at a time, with the policy record open. These calls are about knowing the client, not speed.
  • A large list with several licensed agents on shift: a few lines per agent in power dialing, or predictive dialing if you have enough agents for it. Watch the abandoned call rate every day.

The power vs predictive guide explains the two modes, and the lines per rep guide shows how to set the count from your own answer rate.

Six compliance basics before the first call

1. Calling hours

Paragraph (c)(1) bars telephone solicitations to a residential line before 8 AM or after 9 PM, local time at the called person's location. Some states set tighter hours or limit Sunday and holiday calls; the calling hours guide covers how to check.

2. The national registry

Paragraph (c)(2) bars telephone solicitations to numbers on the national do not call registry. To rely on the rule's safe harbor, your agency needs written procedures, trained staff, a registry version no more than 31 days old at the time of each call, and its own access to the registry data, bought from the registry administrator with no cost sharing arrangement. A dialer that scrubs your list does not replace your agency's own access. The Do Not Call guide walks through the seller's side.

An established business relationship is an exception to the registry rule: under paragraph (f)(5), a purchase or transaction with your agency in the last 18 months, or an inquiry or application in the last three months. A client's request not to be called ends it, even if they keep their policy with you.

3. Your own do not call list

Paragraph (d) requires a written do not call policy, available on demand, and training for everyone who calls. Record a stop request when it is made and honor it within a reasonable time, no more than ten business days. On a live sales call, the agent gives their own name, the agency's name and a phone number or address where the agency can be reached.

Under paragraphs (a)(2) and (a)(3), a telemarketing call to a cell phone with an autodialer or a recorded voice, or a recorded telemarketing message to a home line, needs the person's prior express written consent. Paragraph (f)(9) defines it: a signed written agreement, electronic signatures included, that clearly authorizes the seller to make those calls to a named phone number, and tells the person they do not have to agree to buy anything.

If you buy leads, ask the lead seller for each lead's form, the exact consent wording the person saw, the date and the phone number. Check that the consent authorizes your agency. A list of names and numbers marked "opted in" is not the record.

5. Recorded voicemails

A voicemail drop plays a recorded message, so treat it as a prerecorded voice call. For a telemarketing voicemail, that means the written consent above. Paragraph (b) also sets what every recorded message must say:

  • At the start: the name the agency is registered under with the state.
  • During or after the message: a phone number for the agency.
  • For telemarketing: an automated opt out, and when the message is left on voicemail, a toll free number the person can call back to reach that opt out.

Write one reviewed script for each recorded message, and drop it only on leads whose consent covers recorded calls.

6. Abandoned calls

Paragraph (a)(7) bars abandoning more than 3 percent of telemarketing calls answered by a person, measured over 30 days for each campaign. A call is abandoned when it does not reach a live agent within two seconds of the person's greeting. The abandoned call guide covers the math, the ring time and the message rules.

State rules on top

Insurance is licensed and regulated by each state, and many states add telemarketing rules of their own: registration for telemarketers, their own do not call registry, tighter hours or limits on how often you call. Check your state's insurance department and attorney general before you dial into a new state.

A sample agent opening

Hi, this is [agent first and last name] with [Agency], calling about the [auto insurance] quote you asked for on [Tuesday]. Is now still a good time?

And before you hang up, every time:

If you need us, our number is [number]. And if you'd rather we not call again, just say so and I'll take care of it now.

A one week test before you buy

Ask every dialer vendor to show these with test numbers:

  1. A lead on your own do not call list. Is the call blocked?
  2. A lead whose local time is after 9 PM. Does the call wait?
  3. A lead who says "stop calling" on the call. How does the agent log it, and does every campaign stop?
  4. A recorded voicemail. Where does the script live, and how do you limit it to leads with the right consent?
  5. A campaign report. Can you see the abandoned rate for the last 30 days?
  6. A callback to the number you showed. Does it reach your agency?

Dialing in GameForce

Predictive mode slows down as your abandonment rate climbs.

Local presence calls each lead from a local number you own, matched to the lead's state or area code.

Drop a recorded voicemail in one click and move to the next call.

Do Not Call checked before every call and text.

Your consent records, your own registry access and the wording of each recorded message stay yours to check, whatever dialer you run. See the dialer on our home page.

FAQ

What dialing mode fits a small insurance agency?

Let the lead source decide. Call fresh quote requests one at a time within minutes, work aged leads in power dialing at one line, and use more lines or predictive dialing only with several licensed agents on shift and a daily check of the abandoned call rate.

Can an insurance agency leave prerecorded voicemails?

A dropped voicemail is a recorded message. A telemarketing voicemail needs the person's prior express written consent, and the message must give the agency's registered name at the start, a phone number, and an opt out with a toll free callback number.

Only if the consent record says so. Ask for each lead's form, wording, date and number, and check that it authorizes your agency to make autodialed or recorded calls. A list marked "opted in" is not enough.

Do we need our own registry access if our dialer scrubs the list?

Yes. The safe harbor in the FCC rule expects the caller to buy its own access to the registry data and use a version no more than 31 days old. A dialer's scrub is a tool, not your agency's access.

What hours can insurance agents call?

The federal window for telephone solicitations is 8 AM to 9 PM at the called person's location. Several states are stricter, so check the states you call.

Test your dialer setup

Book a demo and bring the six tests above, or start a free trial.

Put your next step into practice.

See what a clearer sales day can look like.

Read next