Business

Reviews After the Install: When to Ask Every Homeowner, and How to Answer What They Write

Ask every homeowner the same way at the final walkthrough, know the FTC rules on gifts and staff reviews, and answer a bad review without making it worse.

GameForce Team

Reviews After the Install: When to Ask Every Homeowner, and How to Answer What They Write title card

This is general information, not legal advice. Review rules can change, and each review site sets its own. Talk to a lawyer about your own review program.

Homeowners read reviews before they let a contractor on their roof. The way to earn more of them is also the fair one: ask every customer, at the same moment, in the same words, and answer what they write.

The short version: ask at the final walkthrough, every job, no exceptions. Send one follow up, then stop. Never pay for a positive review, never ask only the happy ones, and answer every review, good or bad, without private details.

When to ask: the final walkthrough

The best moment is the end of the final walkthrough, when the homeowner has just seen the finished work and you have just asked whether anything is not right. Make it a fixed step on the close out checklist, so it happens on every job, not only the ones that went smoothly. The signed to paid guide shows where the walkthrough fits.

Pick one person to ask, usually the crew lead or project manager who walked the job. Then send one follow up message a few days later with the link, and stop there.

What to say

At the walkthrough:

"We ask every customer for an honest review, good or bad. It helps other homeowners decide. Here's a card with the link. And if anything isn't right, now or later, call me and we'll fix it either way."

The follow up message, by the channel the homeowner agreed to:

"Hi Jordan, thanks again for choosing us for your new roof. We ask every customer for an honest review. Here's the link. Thank you!"

Notice what these do not say: no "if you were happy", no "five stars", no "call us first before you post". If a homeowner asks you to stop messaging them, stop, and record it. The opt out guide covers the routine.

The FTC rules in plain words

The FTC's consumer review rule and its guide on asking for and paying for reviews set the main federal lines. In short:

  • Ask everyone. The guide says don't ask for reviews only from customers you think will leave positive ones, and don't ask people who never used your service.
  • No fake reviews. The rule bars a business from writing or buying reviews that misstate who the reviewer is, whether they used the service, or what their experience was.
  • No paying for a particular opinion. The rule bars giving money, gift cards, discounts or anything of value in exchange for, or conditioned on, a review that says something positive or negative.
  • Disclose any reward, even with no strings. The guide says that even when a reward does not depend on a positive review, the review should disclose it, because the offer may bias the reviewer. Some review sites ban rewards for reviews entirely, even when disclosed, so check each site's rules before you offer anything.
  • Staff and family must say who they are. The guide says not to ask staff, family or friends for reviews unless they disclose their connection to you. The rule also covers managers who push staff or relatives to post reviews without that disclosure.
  • No threats. The rule bars groundless legal threats, intimidation and public false accusations meant to stop a review or get one taken down.
  • No hiding the bad ones. If your own website shows reviews, do not hide negative ones while presenting the rest as all or most of what you received.
  • You answer for your vendors. The guide warns you can be held responsible for what a reputation company does on your behalf.

Some teams send a private survey first and only send the review link to people who answer happily. That is asking only the customers you expect to be positive, which the FTC guide tells you not to do.

Surveys are still useful. Send the survey and the review link to everyone, separately, and use the survey answers to fix the service, not to decide who gets the link.

Answering a good review

Thank them by name, mention one detail they wrote, and keep it short. No sales pitch and nothing they did not share themselves.

"Thanks, Jordan. We're glad the crew kept the yard clean and finished before the rain. Enjoy the new roof."

Answering a bad review

A bad review is read by every future customer who finds it, so you are writing for them, not winning an argument. Use four steps:

  1. Thank and acknowledge. Say what they are upset about in plain words.
  2. No arguing and no private details. No address, price, payment history or what was said at the kitchen table.
  3. Give a name and a next step. Who will call, and when.
  4. Follow through, then fix the cause.

"Thank you for telling us, Pat. Leaving nails in the driveway is not our standard. Our project manager, Sam, will call you today to set a time to come back and sweep it with a magnet."

If the problem gets fixed, the homeowner may update the review on their own. Do not ask them to change it in exchange for the fix.

Answering a review you cannot match

Sometimes a review describes a job you cannot find. Reply calmly and invite them to reach out:

"We can't find a job under this name. Please call our office so we can look into it."

Use a review site's reporting tool only for reviews that break that site's rules. The FTC guide warns against using it to get rid of honest negative reviews.

Who owns reviews

Give reviews one owner. That person reads every new review within one business day, answers it, and sends any service problem to the project manager who can fix it. Once a month, they list the themes: cleanup, communication, schedule, the crew. Fix the most common one first, and tell the crews what customers praised. The sales to production guide helps when the theme is a broken handoff, and the HVAC sales guide shows the same final walkthrough habit in another trade.

Where GameForce fits

  • Review management

Read every review, answer every review, and fix what they tell you.

FAQ

Can a contractor offer a gift card for a review?

Never in exchange for a positive review: the FTC rule bars rewards tied to what the review says. Even an unconditional reward should be disclosed in the review, according to the FTC guide, and some review sites ban rewards for reviews entirely. Check each site's rules first.

Can I ask only my happy customers for reviews?

No. The FTC guide says not to ask only customers you expect to be positive. Ask every customer the same way.

How should I respond to a negative review?

Thank them, name the problem, give a person and a next step, and keep private details out. Then fix it, and do not ask them to change the review in return.

Can my employees review my business?

Only with a clear disclosure of their connection, according to the FTC guide, and some review sites do not allow it at all. Never ask staff to pose as customers.

Can I get a negative review removed?

Only through the review site's own process, and only if the review breaks its rules. Never threaten a reviewer.

Set up your review routine

Book a demo and bring your close out checklist and your last three reviews, or start a free trial.

Put your next step into practice.

See what a clearer sales day can look like.

Read next